Working document, agent-drafted 2026-08-06, restyled 2026-08-10 (T-029: internal scaffolding, to be rewritten in the author’s own voice before anything reaches Notion). Supersedes: archive/v9_scenario_reply_draft.md (structure taken from archive/v9_scenario_doc_spine.md, errata applied per the v10 split plan §3).

Permissionless Channel Sequencing: the path, each attack, and the asks

The optimistic path first, then how each attack fails, on the actor axis the protocol lead asked for. This is a reply, not a specification; the full arguments live in the four sibling editions and are linked at each point.

Substrate claims carry a tier tag in the text: MERGED (in the merged specification mirror at lips@4c22190f), OPEN PROPOSAL (an unmerged pull request), PROPOSED (this design, unbuilt), NOTION (personal notes, never a spec source). Four proposals below are tagged PROPOSED 06/08; they have since had one hostile read, two came back wounded, and those wounds are disclosed inline rather than buried.

Layer is stated per mechanism: L1 is the base layer (Bedrock/Mantle), L2 is the Sovereign Zone.


1. The optimistic path

Joining

Drawing (evaluated at L1, by every validator identically)

Producing