Status tracker

Authors: Joey Martin

Change log

Revision Description Date
v1 Initial RFC description 2026-08-02

Reviewer Orientation

Read Motivation first; it states the single hazard that shapes every change. Assumes familiarity with the Mantle Specification v1.9.0 (channel operations, Service Declaration Protocol structures) and the Cryptarchia Protocol Specification (epoch schedule, eligibility snapshot, active slot coefficient).

# Priority Change What to look for
1 Critical Start here. Sequencing declaration and note immobilisation new ledger map; new refusal in the shared spendability check; why the locked-note structure is not reused
2 Critical Start here. Slot-win authorisation for channel transfers committee multisignature removed; authorisation by reference to a sibling winning inscription
3 Critical Transaction validation model per-operation validation gains visibility of the operation list; universal transaction path, not a channel operation
4 Critical Channel configuration freeze the guard must test the stored channel’s mode, not the payload’s; a payload-side guard is bypassable and restores committee control
5 High Writer selection by per-channel lottery ticket construction, threshold determinism, the eligibility snapshot
6 High Freshness bound on a winning inscription restores the temporal binding round-robin provides today; open parameter
7 High Withdrawal authorisation the release predicate; least settled normative change here
8 Medium Channel operation gas repricing per-input pricing replaces per-threshold pricing
9 Low Service declaration collateral check unrelated live defect; see Chores

Motivation

Bedrock channels are sequenced by a committee: the first key to write becomes the sole accredited key, and that committee configures the channel, withdraws its funds, and takes turns writing. Membership is governance-managed, so the right to sequence is granted by the parties who already hold it. The objective is an open rule in which depositing is the only admission step.

The difficulty is that the franchise must derive from on-chain state, and the natural state is mutable by the sequencers the lottery selects:

Composed, one win lets a sequencer reset every rival’s note and remain the only eligible writer indefinitely, for the price of one operation. The same operation defeats any correction mechanism that relies on later honest sequencers existing, because its payload is their removal.

The design’s organising principle follows: make the franchise-capturing move invalid at the ledger rather than punishable afterwards, because it is protocol-valid, formally indistinguishable from honest operation, and destroys the actors a punishment layer would depend on.

Layers: lottery, eligibility, declaration, freshness and authorisation rules are Layer 1 (L1) universal, applied by every validator. Zone accounting is Layer 2 (L2) per-zone and the L1 never reads it.