The question

Which post-quantum ZK proof system should the Mantle proof-of-leadership (PoL) circuit use (and then other Logos blockchain circuits)? Constraint that dominates the choice: proof size (every node verifies every PoL proof), with ZK required (the proof must not link to the leader's identity or stake).

The answer

Goldilocks STARK over an RPO-based AIR. It is transparent, fully implemented on a tested prover, and the smallest option that actually works today: ~45 KB non-ZK, ~47 KB with ZK, ~41 ms prove, ~0.87 ms verify. The other candidates lose primarily on proof size.

Why the alternatives lost

Two field/hash choices worth flagging

Open items

References