Owner: @Alexander Mozeika
Goal 1 presents a compelling objective: a participant with no LOGOS should be able to acquire tokens through PoW and enter PoS without purchasing tokens, relying on an existing holder, or obtaining permission from a gatekeeper.
$\boxed{\text{zero-token participant}\rightarrow\text{PoW}\rightarrow\text{LOGOS ownership}\rightarrow\text{PoS participation}}$
However, its current formulation defines an available pathway rather than a measurable outcome. A mechanism could technically be permissionless while remaining ineffective—for example, if newcomers require years to acquire usable stake or if incumbents and professional miners capture most rewards. Goal 1 should therefore specify the intended number of onboarded newcomers, evaluation period, maximum acceptable onboarding time, required retention as active validators, and minimum conversion efficiency from bootstrap rewards into active newcomer stake.
Evaluation should also distinguish genuine initially tokenless newcomers from existing stakeholders, incumbent providers, and external miners; measure the fraction of rewards captured by each group; and ensure that mined stake does not raise adversarial concentration above the PoS safety threshold. Results should be tested under slow, expected, rapid, and burst-adoption scenarios, including persistent mining after participants acquire stake, and reported probabilistically across multiple simulations. In measurable terms, Goal 1 should require that a defined number and proportion of initially tokenless participants become active, retained, and sufficiently independent PoS validators within an agreed time and budget, while limiting incumbent capture, external-miner leakage, and adversarial stake accumulation.
$\boxed{\text{A tokenless participant can mine tokens.}}$
$\quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \big\downarrow$
$\boxed{ \begin{matrix} \text{A defined population of tokenless participants becomes} \\ \text{active, retained, and independent PoS validators} \\ \text{within a defined time and budget.} \end{matrix} }$
Goal 2 seeks to let a person who initially holds no LOGOS access a Logos application by performing PoW, using the resulting reward to fund the claim transaction and an initial useful application action without relying on an exchange, bridge, token holder, or gatekeeper.
$\boxed{\text{zero-token user}\rightarrow\text{perform PoW}\rightarrow\text{self-funded claim}\rightarrow\text{initial application transaction}}$
However, the current formulation describes an available pathway rather than a measurable service outcome. It should define the initial-use bundle to be funded—such as one claim, transfer, and inscription—along with the required reward-to-fee margin, reference hardware, acceptable compute cost, maximum time to first use, and minimum probability that an ordinary user completes the bundle within that time. It should also distinguish practical accessibility for ordinary users from merely allowing anyone to compete against incumbent or professional miners.
The goal should further quantify the intended economic hand-off and operational limits: mining should be practical for the first units of activity but become less attractive than ordinary token acquisition for sustained use, without relying on arbitrary per-user restrictions. Evaluation should measure the hand-off point, robustness under low and volatile network usage, the fraction of PoW rewards associated with useful application activity, and the proportion of block capacity consumed by claims. The current controller better reflects the original low-throughput and emergent-hand-off intention, while de novo offers clearer reward anchoring but can admit excessive bootstrap claim volume; neither can be judged conclusively until the project specifies what initial action must be funded, how quickly, on what hardware, at what cost, and within what block-space limit.
$\boxed{\text{A tokenless user can mine enough tokens to submit a transaction.}}$
$\quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad\quad\quad\quad\quad\big\downarrow$
$\boxed{\begin{gathered}\text{A defined proportion of tokenless users can complete a specified initial-use bundle}\\\text{within a defined time, compute cost, reward margin, and block-space limit,}\\\text{followed by a measurable hand-off to the normal token economy.}\end{gathered}}$
Goal 3 seeks to allow a participant with no LOGOS, validator status, or provider role to perform PoW and send messages through Blend without a gatekeeper.